ROI of implementing gift cards in your online business
Online gift cards: the overlooked growth engine in your restaurant
As a restaurant owner, you’re probably used to thinking in terms of delicious meals, efficient service, and loyal regulars. But there may be an untapped revenue stream in your business that many tend to overlook – online gift cards. Most restaurateurs see gift cards as a nice little extra around the holidays. But in reality, there’s much more at stake. Gift cards aren’t just a thoughtful gesture – they’re a strategic tool that can deliver significant value and a solid return on investment (ROI).
If you don’t currently have a structured system for managing online gift cards, you might be missing out on growth, new customers, and an easy way to improve your bottom line.
With the right digital setup – including a modern restaurant system and an online POS – you can turn gift cards into a steady revenue stream all year round.
Gift cards are no longer just a “Plan B”
In many restaurants, gift cards are introduced as a physical product at the counter during the holiday season. They’re rarely an integrated part of the business strategy — and even more rarely a digital offering that’s systematically marketed online.
Here’s the challenge: You already have guests who want to buy gift cards to share a great experience with others. But if gift cards are only available physically or require manual handling, the sale may be lost entirely — either because it’s too inconvenient for the customer, or because the staff forget to promote it.
By approaching gift cards as a strategic and digital sales channel, you can tap into a valuable business opportunity — one that can deliver significant ROI with very low risk.
What’s the ROI of online gift cards?
Let’s look at the specific ways online gift cards create value:
1: Increased spending per customer
One of the most well-documented effects of gift cards is that customers typically spend 20–30% more than the value of the card. Imagine a guest with a gift card worth 400 DKK — they’ll often end up ordering wine, dessert, or extras they wouldn’t normally have considered. In practice, this means that gift cards don’t just shift revenue — they increase it.
2: New customers – without paying for expensive advertising
Gift cards are often given to people who haven’t visited your restaurant before. This gives you exposure to entirely new – and often high-value – customer segments. These guests will judge your restaurant based on the actual experience, not just your marketing. That means better chances of repeat visits compared to traditional paid advertising.
At the same time, the cost of selling gift cards is minimal. Unlike a discount campaign, which cuts into your margins from day one, gift cards give you full payment upfront — with the added possibility that the balance may never even be redeemed.
3: Breakage – no service, full revenue
An often overlooked aspect is what’s known as “breakage” — gift cards that are never redeemed. Industry data typically shows a non-redemption rate of 5–10%. While this may seem like an ethical dilemma, the reality is that it’s a calculated part of the business model. When accounted for properly, breakage contributes directly to your bottom line.
Example: If you sell 100,000 DKK worth of gift cards annually and 7% go unredeemed, that’s 7,000 DKK in revenue without delivering any service. No extra seats, no additional staff, no ingredients required.
Less administration, greater return
Many restaurant owners hesitate to offer gift cards because they worry about the hassle of accounting, tracking, and expiration rules. But this is exactly where the right technology makes all the difference. A modern restaurant system like Flexybox fully integrates gift cards into your sales and POS setup.
That means:
- Automatic registration in your online POS system
- Clear display of balance, expiration date, and amount used
- Option to sell online directly through your website or social media
- Integration with loyalty programs and customer clubs
- Minimal administration and 100% real-time overview
If you’re already using a digital POS system, you’re one big step closer to leveraging gift cards as a strategic opportunity. If not, it’s an investment that quickly pays for itself — through higher conversion rates and more efficient operations alone.
A new standard for restaurants
In an industry defined by low margins and high guest volume per operating hour, it’s crucial to find revenue streams that scale without adding more hands in the kitchen. Gift cards are exactly that kind of opportunity. They’re one of the few ways to increase both revenue and profit — without extending opening hours, hiring more staff, or investing in additional equipment.
Major players have long understood the value. In 2020, nearly 50% of Starbucks’ revenue came from gift cards. This wasn’t just about gift-giving — it was the result of a strong digital platform and effective use of customer data. Small and medium-sized restaurants can achieve the exact same effect — if they’re willing to think differently and embrace the right technology.
How do you get started?
- Choose a restaurant system that supports seamless integration and includes a gift card module – for example, Flexybox, which connects directly with your online POS and makes it easy to sell and manage gift cards both physically and digitally.
- Make gift cards easily accessible on your website and social media channels. Implement a “Buy Now” button and ensure the purchase can be completed in just a few clicks — even from a mobile device.
- Promote gift cards consistently — not just during the holidays. Email campaigns and Facebook ads with messages like “The Perfect Gift” work year-round, especially when timed with customer milestones such as birthdays or anniversaries.
- Consider integrating with loyalty programs: Offer points or benefits to both the sender and the recipient of the gift card. This strengthens the relationship and increases the likelihood of repeat purchases.
Time to start thinking ROI — like a restaurateur
There’s no doubt that the restaurant industry is highly competitive and demands tough prioritization. That’s exactly why it’s essential to focus on solutions that are both scalable and profitable. Online gift cards aren’t just a charming gift idea — they’re a proven strategy for growing your customer base, increasing average order value, and boosting your business’s overall worth.
By integrating gift cards into your digital operations — through a robust restaurant system and a flexible online POS – you position your business to harness one of the most overlooked growth engines in the restaurant industry.
Would you like to learn more about how Flexybox can help you unlock higher ROI through online gift cards?
Contact our sales team today for a no-obligation conversation.
Let's find a solution for you?
Contact us, if we have left you curious on our products and benefits by collecting your operation to one system.
It’s non-binding to have a call or book a presentation.